The City of Key West now plans to tear down White Street Pier and build a new one. That decision is in the city's adopted capital plan for the fiscal year that began October 1, 2026. It schedules the full demolition of the Edward B. Knight Pier, the name the city uses for White Street Pier, as the last stage of a 25-year program. Along the same shoreline, the Reynolds Street Pier at Higgs Beach was built in the 1940s and has been closed since Hurricane Ian. It is set for a repair, not a replacement.
So Casa Marina's two piers are now on two different timelines. One has a planned end of life. The other is being repaired one more time.
Last year's plan was a repair list
The change shows up when you put the city's two most recent capital plans next to each other. In the FY 2025/26 plan, project IS72012502 was called "White Street Pier Rehabilitation," and the job description was three sentences long: redo the riprap retaining wall around the pier, repair the sidewalks and resurface the pier, and inspect and replace lights and wiring as needed.
The FY 2026/27 plan keeps the same project number. It now carries the pier's formal name and describes something much bigger.
| FY 2025/26 plan | FY 2026/27 plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Project name | White Street Pier Rehabilitation | Edward B Knight Pier Rehabilitation |
| Project estimate | $11,077,736 | $28,572,000 |
| Scope | Riprap wall, sidewalks, resurfacing, lights and wiring | Phased repairs, rehabilitation and full reconstruction over 25 years |
| Long-term outcome | Not described | Demolition and a new pier designed for a 75 to 100 year service life |
| Listed project window | 10/01/25 to 09/30/27 | 10/1/2025 to 9/30/2027 |
Both sheets list the same two-year project window, ending 9/30/2027, and the project number never changed. That window lines up with the first stage of safety work, while the new sheet's description runs 25 years past the start. The estimate grew by about $17.5 million because the plan now covers the pier's whole remaining life, not just the next round of fixes.
Twenty-five years, in three stages
The new plan says the work is meant to "maintain safe public use while preparing for end-of-life replacement." It sets out three stages.
- The first two years: critical safety repairs. That means replacing light poles, rebuilding collapsed and settling sidewalk, adding riprap, and repairing stormwater inlets that the plan says have severe corrosion and backfill loss.
- Years five through ten: targeted rebuilding of damaged seawall cap sections, knee wall repairs, spalling repairs on the bridge spans, new railing anchor bolts, asphalt resurfacing and more sidewalk stabilization.
- Years fifteen through twenty-five: complete replacement. The plan calls for demolishing the existing structure and building a new seawall, bridge spans, pavement, railings, lighting, flowable-fill backfill and drainage.
If you count from the project's October 2025 start date, the replacement stage would fall between roughly 2040 and 2050. Until then, the repairs are meant to keep a deteriorating structure open and safe, not to make it new again. The plan says the mid-term work is meant to keep the pier "functional as deterioration progresses."
Where the money actually lands first
The $28,572,000 figure is a 25-year estimate. The near-term budget is much smaller. The FY 2026/27 plan shows $150,074 committed or spent to date and $1,928,964 for this fiscal year, almost all of it construction. The next money in the schedule is $2,193,000 in FY 2029/30.
Together that comes to about $4.27 million through the five years the plan covers, roughly 15 percent of the total estimate. The rest falls outside the current planning window. That fits a program where the costly demolition and rebuild come last.
This fiscal year's money is the part that affects your walk now. It pays for the safety items on the list: light poles, the collapsed and settling sidewalk, riprap and inlets. The plan doesn't name a contractor or set work dates beyond the fiscal year, so how the repairs will be staged on the pier isn't yet public.
Reynolds Street Pier has a different problem
The Reynolds Street Pier at Higgs Beach is in a different position, both physically and legally.
It was built in the 1940s and rehabilitated in 1989 and again in 2018. It closed after Hurricane Ian and was inspected in November 2022. The city's project sheet sums up that inspection as "widespread but non-critical deterioration" in the timber beams, decking, concrete bent caps and prestressed piles. The listed problems are missing deck fasteners, timber beams that are splitting and twisting, cracking and spalling concrete, and cracked piles at the waterline. The same sheet says the pier "remains structurally sound." The inspection recommended two levels of work: quick corrective fixes to stabilize the parts at risk of getting worse, then fuller structural repairs.
So White Street Pier's plan ends in replacement, while Reynolds is headed for its third rehabilitation. The basis of design is Monroe County's Bridge Assessment Report.
The pier is now the city's to fix. The Key West Citizen reported in its column on the city taking over Higgs Beach that the County handed the beach to the City at a ceremony on April 30, 2026, with City management starting May 1. The pier and its repairs and maintenance came with it. A week later, on May 7, 2026, the City Commission passed a grant award that assigns $259,448 to City repairs at the Reynolds Street Pier as part of the Higgs Beach transfer.
Here is the FY 2026/27 budget for the rehab, which totals $1,255,884:
- Design: $100,000
- Planning and permitting: $150,000
- Construction: $827,884
- Furnishings and equipment: $178,000
Most of the money comes from tourist development grants. The plan lists $196,436 from Fund 101, $259,448 as a Monroe County BOCC tourist development grant, and $800,000 as a TDC grant. In its coverage of community concerns about Higgs Beach, the Key West Citizen described that roughly $800,000 as a TDC request for pier work and gave no firm delivery date.
The project's start date is 10/1/2026, and its end date is listed as "TBD." The plan describes survey, design and construction, with no reopening date. Anyone hoping to fish from Reynolds this winter should read "TBD" literally.
What the White Street clock has to work around
The Key West AIDS Memorial sits at its foot, where White Street meets Atlantic Boulevard. Keys Weekly reported in 2023 that the memorial was built with private funds, donated to the City in 1997, and was the first municipal AIDS memorial in the world. The Key West Citizen has reported that Friends of the AIDS Memorial maintains the site, a City park, and holds the World AIDS Day remembrance there.
The pier is also used for organized events. At its April 1, 2026 meeting, the City Commission approved the Reelin for the Cause Kids Fishing Tournament on the Edward B. Knight Pier for Saturday, April 25, 2026, from 3:00 to 8:30 p.m.
Both depend on the pier staying open through years of repairs. That explains why the first two years focus on safety items like lighting, sidewalk and drainage. Those are the parts a person walking out at dusk actually touches.
The road at the base of both piers
Atlantic Boulevard runs between the two piers, and it has a timeline of its own. The FY 2026/27 plan lists a $3,471,014 rehabilitation of Atlantic Boulevard from Bertha Street to White Street. The project started April 15, 2026, and is scheduled to end December 31, 2027. It covers design, permitting and construction documents for roadway and drainage improvements, including new inlets, regrading and raising the pavement where feasible. The plan budgets $3,275,332 for construction this fiscal year, mostly from bond funding. That money is listed in the budget but isn't yet on a posted work calendar.
That means three public projects are lined up along Casa Marina's shoreline: a road being redesigned, a small pier waiting on its third rehab, and a big pier whose plan now sets a replacement horizon. Each runs on its own schedule. The White Street schedule is the longest, at 25 years.
If you're weighing what these waterfront projects mean for a home near Atlantic Boulevard, or you just want to talk through how public work along the shore fits into a Casa Marina sale or purchase, Dan Serban is glad to go over it with you. Contact Dan.