"The Sugarloaf Showdown has always been about more than the fishing," Jessyca LaBadie, the Lower Keys Guides Association's tournament director and operations manager, told Florida Keys Weekly in August. "It's a chance for our community to come together, spend time on the water with family and friends and celebrate the incredible fishery that makes the Lower Keys so special."
From Thursday, Nov. 12, through Saturday, Nov. 14, the 13th annual Showdown takes over Sugarloaf Marina and the grassy point at Sugarloaf Lodge. The guides association built it to bring anglers to the Lower Keys during the quieter fall season. It started as a small, homegrown tournament and is now one of the region's most anticipated fishing events. The guides who work these flats every day run it. It is scored by photo, so every fish goes back in the water, and the money it raises goes to guides who end up off the water.
Everything happens at MM 17
The whole tournament happens at two neighboring properties on the Overseas Highway. Sugarloaf Marina is at 17015 Overseas Hwy. in Sugarloaf Shores. The marina describes itself as one of the last "old school" marinas in the Keys, sits beside the historic Sugarloaf Lodge, and calls itself a community hub for decades. The Lodge is on the Gulf side at Mile Marker 17.
Its everyday business also serves the tournament. The ship's store sells tackle and live and frozen bait, and the marina has fuel, a boat ramp, a shallow kayak ramp, kayak and paddleboard rentals, boat rentals, eco tours and fishing guides. Check-in, the rules meeting, launches, returns and scoring all happen there. On Saturday night everyone walks next door to the Lodge.
The tournament runs on a fixed clock
If you launch at Sugarloaf Marina, fish the nearby flats or just drive past MM 17 that weekend, you can plan around the posted schedule. It is the same on both fishing days.
| Day | Time | What happens | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thursday, Nov. 12 | 4–6 p.m. | Registration, check-in, bag and rules pickup | Sugarloaf Marina |
| Thursday, Nov. 12 | 4 p.m. | Auction opens; Papa's Pilar rum bar and keg | Sugarloaf Marina |
| Thursday, Nov. 12 | 5:30 p.m. | Rules meeting | Sugarloaf Marina |
| Friday, Nov. 13 | 6:30–7:30 a.m. | Mandatory check-in with the scorekeeper | Sugarloaf Marina |
| Friday, Nov. 13 | 7:30 a.m. | Lines in; boats leave the marina | On the water |
| Friday, Nov. 13 | 4 p.m. | Lines out | On the water |
| Friday, Nov. 13 | 5:30 p.m. | All boats back and checked in | Sugarloaf Marina |
| Saturday, Nov. 14 | 6:30 a.m.–5:30 p.m. | Same fishing-day schedule as Friday | Marina and water |
| Saturday, Nov. 14 | 6 p.m. | Awards dinner and Papa's Pilar rum bar, with Cayo Hueso Brewing's Skinny Water Lager | Sugarloaf Lodge grassy point |
| Saturday, Nov. 14 | 8 p.m. | Auction closes | Sugarloaf Lodge |
On both mornings, expect the marina to be busiest between 6:30 and 7:30, when every team has to check in with the scorekeeper before leaving. The second rush comes in the late afternoon. Lines come out at 4 p.m., and at least one person from each team has to bring the scoresheet and photos back to Sugarloaf Marina by 5:30 p.m.
The tournament is open to all anglers. The guides association still gives its own members first chance at a spot. For 2026, registration opened to current members only from Aug. 1 through Aug. 14, and to the general public from Aug. 15 if space was left. The entry fee is $350 per boat. The 2025 field filled in less than 48 hours, and a waitlist formed. For this year's status, the registration page is the place to check. Its policy says a free waitlist registration opens if the field reaches capacity.
Fish are scored by photo and released
This is a catch-and-release tournament. Fly and spin anglers compete for bonefish, permit and barracuda. No fish come to a scale. Every fish has to be photographed, and the photos are shown to the scorekeeper. Barracuda photos have to include the measuring device the tournament provides. The tournament rules call for minimal handling and encourage taking photos with the fish in the water.
That is why the 5:30 p.m. return at the marina looks like teams gathered around phones instead of a weigh station. It also shows how the scoring rewards a team. In 2025, the spin grand champions caught three species for 850 points. The fly grand champions caught two species and scored 1,200 points. The youth grand champion, an 11-year-old, caught one species for 100 points. A team that catches fewer kinds of fish can still win, depending on what it catches and how.
The youth division is for anglers 12 and under. Young anglers are entered in the youth category automatically and can also place in the spin division if their scores are high enough. The 2026 announcement says the division makes the tournament popular with fishing families.
The auction money goes to guides
The tournament raises money for the Guides Trust Foundation, which helps fishing guides who are recovering from an illness or injury. The foundation says its work benefits Florida Keys inshore guides, the fishery and the communities around them, and its site takes donations directly. According to Florida Keys Weekly, the foundation helped several Lower Keys guides last year who were off the water for months.
The same Lower Keys guides association that organizes the tournament puts its fundraising toward its own working community, so the bids placed at MM 17 go back to the people who fish the flats around it.
The tournament's own pages describe the auction two ways. The schedule calls it a silent auction that opens Thursday at 4 p.m. at the marina and closes Saturday at 8 p.m. The July 30 announcement from Visit Florida Keys & Key West calls it an online auction. SugarloafShowdown.com is the best place to see how bidding works this year and how to take part.
Local businesses back it
The 2026 sponsor list is mostly places Lower Keys residents already know:
- Sugarloaf Marina
- Sugarloaf Lodge
- Cayo Hueso Brewing
- Square Grouper Bar & Grill
- Mangrove Mama's
- Murray's Market
- Broil Steakhouse
- FishWife Key West
- The Docks
The two businesses at the top are the two the tournament runs out of. Cayo Hueso Brewing also supplies the Skinny Water Lager at Saturday's dinner. The guides association's fall tournament gets much of its support from businesses along U.S. 1 between Key West and the Lower Keys.
Fire Station 10 is being rebuilt
A different kind of community project started on Sugarloaf this fall. According to Florida Keys Weekly on Oct. 22, Monroe County crews began preparing to demolish and replace Sugarloaf Key Fire Station 10. The work begins with interior preparation and equipment staging, followed by demolition. A two-story, 8,320-square-foot station will replace the old building, which the county says has structural and maintenance problems that are no longer economically repairable.
The community asked for a multipurpose room, and the new plans include one. The county expects a ceremonial groundbreaking in early December and completion in late 2027. Meanwhile, firefighters are working from a temporary location, and fire rescue service in the Sugarloaf area has continued without interruption. The county says it will share details about the groundbreaking once plans are final.
That puts two community calendars on the same stretch of the Overseas Highway this fall. The Showdown fills the marina and the Lodge's grassy point for three days in mid-November, and the groundbreaking for the new fire station, with its new community room, follows in early December.
Whether you know the Sugarloaf Marina ramp from fishing or from your own dock down the road, I'm glad to talk about life on Sugarloaf Key and the Lower Keys, from a weekend like this one to what a home on this stretch is like year-round. Contact Dan at Dan Serban anytime.