An elegantly set table for two beside calm blue-green water on a tropical island at sunset.

Holiday Dinner at Latitudes on Sunset Key, Planned Around the Ferry

When you book a table at Latitudes, you're booking a seat on a boat. The restaurant sits on Sunset Key, and dinner guests who aren't staying on the island board at Slip 29 behind Opal Key Resort, 245 Front St. Your reservation time is the time that boat leaves. Thanksgiving is one week from today, and Latitudes has posted dinners for Thanksgiving, Christmas Day and New Year's Eve, each with a set service window and reservations taken by phone. For a Key West local, the boat schedule decides which table times work, so it's the first thing to plan around.

Your reservation time is your departure time

According to the Sunset Key Cottages FAQ, people who aren't resort guests can dine at Latitudes with a confirmed reservation. The ferry leaves from the marina at Opal Key Resort near Mallory Square. The restaurant's OpenTable listing adds the details that matter on the dock. Check in at Slip 29 eight to ten minutes before your reservation time. You can't board before that time.

In practice, a 6:45 dinner reservation means the 6:45 boat, and arriving early for the 6:15 doesn't get you on it. The ride across is about seven minutes.

The scheduled boats leave Opal Key at 15 and 45 minutes past each hour, from 6:45 a.m. to 10:45 p.m. Return boats leave Sunset Key on the hour and the half hour. After 11 p.m., the boat runs by request. Every plan below is built on that schedule.

Booking itself is by phone. The OpenTable page says Latitudes isn't on its booking network. Each holiday page asks you to call 305-292-5394.

The three holiday dinners side by side

The 2026 holiday menus were posted in late October. They're à la carte, with each dish priced separately and a priced wine pairing listed beside most dishes.

Holiday, 2026 Day of week Service window Main course prices listed
Thanksgiving, Nov. 26 Thursday Noon to 9 p.m. $32 to $58
Christmas, Dec. 25 Friday Noon to 9 p.m. $32 to $68
New Year's Eve, Dec. 31 Thursday 5 to 10 p.m. Items include scallops at $50 and a bone-in strip at $78

Thanksgiving and Christmas both open at noon. That means a midday boat is an option, and an early holiday meal on an island off Old Town needs no special arrangements. New Year's Eve is a dinner-only service that ends at 10 p.m.

What Thanksgiving costs next to a regular night

The Thanksgiving menu starts with three first courses. There's a butternut squash and pumpkin bisque with pepitas and truffle honey for $16, roasted beets with goat cheese and candied walnuts for $17, and shrimp cocktail for $24.

The second course has four choices. The traditional Thanksgiving dinner is $50. It comes with roasted heritage turkey, chicken apple sausage stuffing, Yukon mashed potatoes, sage gravy, mushroom green bean casserole, glazed heirloom carrots and a cherry and cranberry relish. A lobster and crab stuffed red snapper is also $50. A 12-ounce prime rib is $58, and a wild mushroom risotto is $32.

Those prices fall inside the range of the restaurant's everyday dinner menu, which was updated in late September. That menu runs from a $15 Maine lobster bisque to an $82 eight-ounce filet. Simply prepared grouper is $56, a New York strip is $68 and a Colorado lamb rack is $67. On Thanksgiving, the stuffed snapper costs $6 less than a regular night's grouper. The 12-ounce prime rib costs $10 less than the regular strip. A table that orders the turkey dinner is paying everyday prices for a holiday meal.

The holiday pages list a wine with nearly every dish. The listed wine prices run from $15 for the Benvolio Pinot Grigio and the Chateau Ste Michelle Dry Riesling to $19 for The Prisoner Chardonnay.

Christmas Day falls on a Friday

Christmas dinner runs from noon to 9 p.m. on Dec. 25, with reservations required by phone. Mains range from the mushroom risotto at $32 to prime rib at $68.

On an ordinary Friday, Latitudes serves dinner until 11 p.m. The Christmas window closes two hours earlier, so a late-evening Christmas table isn't available this year the way it would be on a normal weekend night.

That window lines up with the ferry. With seating ending at 9 p.m., a Christmas dinner that runs long still finishes while return boats are leaving Sunset Key every half hour.

New Year's Eve ends right where the schedule changes

The New Year's Eve dinner is the one where timing takes the most thought. Service runs from 5 to 10 p.m. on Thursday, Dec. 31. The last scheduled boat from Opal Key leaves at 10:45 p.m. Return boats from Sunset Key leave on the hour and half hour, and after 11 p.m. they run by request.

So a late seating puts you at the end of the scheduled boats. A party that finishes dessert near 10 can count on the 10:30 and 11:00 boats back. Anyone planning to cross after that is relying on the by-request service. An earlier seating leaves more room on the return, and it gets you back to Front Street with time left before midnight.

Weather, dress and parking

December weather can affect a dinner that depends on a boat. The OpenTable listing says indoor seating at Latitudes is limited, and reservations may not be guaranteed in bad weather. If a front is forecast for your night, it's worth calling ahead.

The dress code is upscale resort attire. For men, that means a collared shirt with shorts or slacks and no tank tops. For women, it means a casual dress, shorts or slacks. Beachwear isn't allowed. That's a looser standard than holiday dining often calls for. Shorts are fine as long as the shirt has a collar.

For anyone driving in from New Town, Key Haven or farther up the Keys, the Sunset Key Cottages FAQ lists the Opal Key garage at $30 per night for self-parking and $40 per night for valet at the Opal Key entrance, as of mid-October 2026. Those are the resort's per-night rates, so ask about parking for dinner when you call to book. If you live in Old Town, the dock is close enough that walking down Front Street to Slip 29 avoids the garage entirely.

Breakfast and lunch on Sunset Key

If the holiday dinner is booked or doesn't fit your plans, Latitudes serves breakfast and lunch every day. The first scheduled boat leaves Opal Key at 6:45 a.m. That makes a morning crossing easy for out-of-town guests visiting over the holidays. The menu includes Key Lime French Toast at $18, shrimp and grits at $28 and crab Benedict at $30.

The same ferry schedule applies at breakfast. The reservation time is the departure time, and you check in at Slip 29 a few minutes early. If your December weekend is already filling up with the lighted boat parades, our guide to the two December boat parades lists those dates. Morning on Sunset Key and evening at the Key West Bight fit into the same holiday visit.

If a ride over from Slip 29 has you curious about the island's homes or how ownership works there, my Sunset Key neighborhood page is a good place to start, and I'm glad to talk it through with you. Contact Dan at Dan Serban.

Work With Dan

Luxury Florida real estate requires a different level of discretion, presentation, and negotiation. That is exactly what I deliver for every client I represent.

Follow Me on Instagram